People tend to stick with the current arrangement, even when alternatives might serve them better. Researchers call this status quo bias. It is part of why many policies renew year after year without a close look.
Why we stay
- Change takes effort, and the cost of doing nothing is invisible.
- We worry that switching could introduce a mistake or a gap.
- The current option is familiar, and familiar feels safe.
What gets missed
- Changes in your life, such as a new vehicle, a renovation, a new business, or a change in who depends on you.
- Features or limits that have changed at renewal.
- Questions you never asked, because nothing prompted you to.
A renewal habit that is not a big project
About a month before a policy renews:
- Read the renewal notice, not just the price.
- Check what changed from last year.
- Write down anything that changed in your own life.
- Ask your insurer or advisor what the changes mean.
- Decide on purpose whether to keep, adjust or look around.
Our Renewal Prep tool can help you make the list.
A note on switching
Changing insurers can be sensible for some people and not for others. Before cancelling anything, check what the new policy covers, when it starts, and whether any waiting periods or conditions apply, so there is no gap.
Questions to ask
- What changed on this renewal compared with last year?
- What changed in my life?
- Would I choose this arrangement if I were starting today?
This is general information, not advice.
